Remember? The idea was scrapped after we figured not everyone here can own the same game. It was going to be a co-operative review, so it doesn't work.
It could still be cooperative between all the people who own the game. We can democratically decide what game to review, and then everyone who has it can contribute.
Well - hypothetically here - we'd just choose a game, and whoever has it or has the time to do it or whatever could join in a roundtable discussion on it, culminating with our individual thumbs up, thumbs down ratings.